Lot and his daughters: a troubling tale of sin and seduction (2024)

The Old Testament is filled with dramatic and often unsettling stories, but few are more shocking and morally charged as that of Lot and his daughters.

The story is recounted in Genesis 19: 1–38. Lot, his wife and two daughters were visited by two angels who urged them to flee the city of Sodom before its imminent destruction by God. As they fled, Lot's wife disobeyed the angels' command to not look back and was turned into a pillar of salt.

Lot and his daughters took refuge inside a cave near the mountain town of Zoar. Believing that there were no men left alive, the two chaste daughters conspired to get their father drunk with wine and each conceive a child by him in order to continue the family line. The incestuous relations resulted in the birth of Moab and Ben-Ammi, founders of the Moabites and Ammonites.

The obvious question is why have artists over the centuries been drawn to this grim and disturbing episode? As a cautionary tale on the dangers of lust and alcohol, the biblical narrative held obvious appeal to artists in past centuries, but it also raised more profoundly complex questions about duty, sacrifice, free will and circ*mstance. The story has long been open to various interpretations, many of which are reflected in art.

An early example of the subject in Western painting can be found by Lucas Cranach the elder,now in the collection ofCompton Verney, Warwickshire.

Lot and His Daughters c.1530

Lucas Cranach the elder (1472–1553)

Compton Verney

Cranach combined the key moments of the episode to create a highly descriptive visual narrative. Tellingly, Cranach used most of the composition to depict the duplicitous behaviour of Lot's daughters. While one daughter pours the wine, the other caresses Lot's head and draws him closer to her, thus blurring the line between affection and deceit.

In Cranach's time, the story was widely considered by many as a warning about the cunning of women. In this respect, the painting relates to the broader themes known as Weibermacht and Weiberlisten (power of women, wiles of women) that were popular in the decorative arts and literature of the late medieval period.

The seventeenth century saw the story of Lot and his daughters reach the peak of its popularity, most notably in Italy where highly moralising stories were commissioned by public institutions and private citizens. Unlike earlier artists, Baroque painters became more selective on which part of the narrative to depict. Guido Reni, for example, focused on Lot and his daughters fleeing Sodom.

The trio are shown in conversation as they hurry to safety. Interestingly, Reni decided to depict Lot as a sober patriarch rather than a befuddled and bleary-eyed old man as favoured by other artists. Furthermore, there is no suggestion that the daughters are seductive temptresses. They are fully clothed and appear rational but apprehensive about what to do next. Reni reminds us that they are young women thrown into turmoil through no fault of their own.

In contrast to Reni's restrained picture, Giovanni Francesco Guerrieri could not resist illustrating the sensual eroticism that the story implied. He has depicted Lot's daughters dressed in low cut gowns and tight bodices, their upper bodies starkly illuminated by an oil lamp. Lot meanwhile is partially clothed and stares helplessly at the poured wine as if on the verge of drunken indignity. Cleverly, Guerrieri has used the newly fashionable chiaroscuro style to create a heightened sense of drama and convey the cave setting in which the narrative plays out.

Lot and His Daughters 1617–1618

Giovanni Francesco Guerrieri (1589–1656)

Manchester Art Gallery

What is perhaps most interesting about Guerrieri's canvas is the allusion that Lot's daughters are performing a necessary, albeit disturbing, duty to continue the lineage of their father, and therefore the human race. And while the theme of female trickery still looms large – notice the comforting but persuasive hand upon Lot's bare shoulder – the daughters are both focused intently on carrying out their plan with an emotionless efficiency.

Is the artist suggesting that all three are victims of circ*mstance rather than purposefully driven to commit sinful acts? It is also worth remembering that within the context of Old Testament morality, being childless was itself a social stigma to be avoided if possible. Whatever Guerrieri's intentions, his painting effectively captures both the moral dilemmas and ambiguities of the story.

The subject continued to be painted by artists throughout the seventeenth century, but often without the same degree of high drama found in previous artistic representations. Marcantonio Franceschini's version of the subject is imbued with an almost graceful classicism.

Lot and His Daughters after 1676–1677

Marcantonio Franceschini (1648–1729)

Dulwich Picture Gallery

The relaxed poses, flowing robes and soft colours combine to lessen the emotional intensity of the scene. Yet there is one notable and disquieting aspect of the painting. Here, Lot appears to be a more active participant in the events and not the disengaged character usually seen. He looks down at his seated daughter while his right hand lingers worryingly over her upper body.

Lot's culpability in the story was often excused due to his inebriated state, but the notion that he was unaware of his actions is called into question in Franceschini's canvas. He also appears to be a much physically stronger and robust man than the usual portrayal of him as a weak, feeble figure.

The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries saw relatively few artistic depictions of the story. A rare example of the subject in Victorian art can be seen in Edward Burne-Jones' design for a stained glass window.

Lot and His Daughters (cartoon for a stained glass window)1874

Edward Burne-Jones (1833–1898)

The Higgins Bedford

The divide between youth and old age seems to have been uppermost in the mind of Burne-Jones. Lot appears elderly and frail, hunched forward and struggling to keep pace with his daughters. Most striking, however, is the stylised treatment of the subject. Looming above the protagonists is a wide rhythmical mass of flame-like curves and swirls, suggesting the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah and conveying a hurried sense of urgency.

One would not expect to find many examples of the Lot story in twentieth-century art, least of all in sculpture, and yet there are two highly distinctive artworks in three-dimensional form that are arguably more uncompromising and perturbing than any previous versions of the subject. The first is by the little-known Russian-Canadian sculptor Abraham (also known as Abrasha) Lozoff.

Lot and His Daughters 1926

Abraham Lozoff (1887–1936)

Ben Uri Collection

Combining the dual influences of Paul Gauguin and African tribal carvings, Lozoff depicted Lot and his daughters in sensuously elongated poses. The trio's entangled grouping not only conveys the physical acts that took place, but also the moral complexity of their interaction.

A similar approach is evident in a sculpture by Arthur William Henry Pears. The trio are completely nude and both daughters are in close physical contact with their father.

Lot and His daughters 1984

Arthur William Henry Pears (1918–2003)

Buxton Museum & Art Gallery

Their interlocking poses and gestures make for a deeply uncomfortable work, but one in which the physical and psychological aspects of the episode are expressed without compromise.

Even in our increasingly secular and liberal age, the biblical story of Lot and his daughters has lost little of its shock value and remains an undeniably troubling but compelling narrative.

The many visual depictions it has inspired are almost certain to draw a response from the viewer. With its interweaving themes of temptation, temperance, deception, selflessness and female empowerment, the story will no doubt continue to exert a timeless fascination.

Jonathan Hajdamach, independent art historian

Enjoyed this story? Get all the latest Art UK stories sent directly to your inbox when you sign up for our newsletter.

Lot and his daughters: a troubling tale of sin and seduction (2024)


Lot and his daughters: a troubling tale of sin and seduction? ›

Believing that there were no men left alive, the two chaste daughters conspired to get their father drunk with wine and each conceive a child by him in order to continue the family line. The incestuous relations resulted in the birth of Moab and Ben-Ammi, founders of the Moabites and Ammonites.

What is the sin of Lot's daughters? ›

According to Esther Fuchs, the text presents Lot's daughters as the "initiators and perpetrators of the incestuous 'rape'". Alter agrees, adding that when the elder daughter says "let us lie with him", the meaning of the Hebrew verb in this context "seems close to 'rape'".

What does the Bible say about Lot and his daughters? ›

Lot and his two daughters left Zoar and settled in the mountains, for he was afraid to stay in Zoar. He and his two daughters lived in a cave. One day the older daughter said to the younger, "Our father is old, and there is no man around here to lie with us, as is the custom all over the earth.

What is the painting of Lot and his daughters? ›

Lot and His Daughters is a 1622 painting by Orazio Gentileschi. Executed in oil on canvas, the large painting depicts the Biblical tale of Lot and his two daughters after the destruction of Sodom. Lot and His Daughters (1622), J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles.

What happened to Lot in the end? ›

After the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, Lot was afraid to stay in Zoar and so he and his two daughters resettled into the hills, living in a cave.

Why did Lot's daughters do such a thing? ›

Both of Lot's daughters became pregnant through this sexual abuse of their own father. Why would they do such a thing? Their stated reason was they assumed no man was left who would marry them and give them children.

What was Lot's wife's sin? ›

When she goes to her women neighbors for salt to give her husband's guests, she makes it known to the town that Lot is harboring guests. The townspeople storm Lot's house and remove his guests. Lot's wife sinned thus through salt, and for this she is turned into a pillar of salt.

What is the spiritual meaning of Lot? ›

Lot, meaning dark-colored, covering, hidden, can also be said to symbolize the part of man's consciousness that is still in darkness--in other words, the natural or animal man.

Why did Lot's wife look back in the Bible? ›

In Judaism, one common view of Lot's wife turning to salt was as punishment for disobeying the angels' warning. By looking back at the "evil cities," she betrayed her secret longing for that way of life. She was deemed unworthy to be saved and thus was turned to a pillar of salt.

What was the sin of Sodom and Gomorrah? ›

Judaism. Later Hebrew prophets named the sins of Sodom and Gomorrah as adultery, pridefulness, and uncharitableness. Rictor Norton views classical Jewish texts as stressing the cruelty and lack of hospitality of the inhabitants of Sodom to the "stranger".

What is the point of the story of Lot and his daughters? ›

They argue that Lot exhibits selfish and harmful behavior throughout his life; one midrash argues that the daughters' relations with their father are punishment for his choices, while another says that he secretly desired his daughters.

How is Ruth related to Lot? ›

Indeed, the marriage of Ruth and Boaz brings together the lines of Lot and Abraham that were separated in Genesis 13. Lot is the father of Moab and thus the ancestor of Ruth; Abraham is the father of Judah, who is the father of Perez, and Boaz comes from the line of Perez (4.18-22).

What is the story of the Lot painting? ›

The story of Lot and his daughters comes from the nineteenth chapter of the Book of Genesis. In the foreground, Lot and his two children are portrayed fleeing from the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, which erupt in blinding explosions of fire in the background.

Where is Sodom and Gomorrah today? ›

Historicity. Sodom and Gomorrah are possibly located under or adjacent to the shallow waters south of Al-Lisān, a former peninsula in the central part of the Dead Sea in Israel that now fully separates the sea's northern and southern basins.

Was Lot's wife turned into a pillar of salt? ›

Lot's wife is the only one of the escaping family to disobey the warning. When God sends “brimstone and fire” (Gen 19:24) on sinful Sodom, its sister city Gomorrah, and all the cities in the area, Lot's wife looks back. Because she disobeys the warning, she becomes “a pillar of salt” (Gen 19:26).

Who are the Moabites today? ›

Outside of the Bible, many secular sources corroborate the existence of the Moabites and their interactions with the Israelites. Moabites today do not exist as a separate people but their descendants may include some of the people of Jordan who live in the biblical territory of Moab.

What do Lot's daughters do to him? ›

Is incest a sin in the Bible? ›

Incest in the Bible refers to sexual relations between certain close kinship relationships which are prohibited by the Hebrew Bible. These prohibitions are found predominantly in Leviticus 18:7–18 and 20:11–21, but also in Deuteronomy.

What is it called when a father sleeps with his daughter? ›

Incest, therefore, is a cultural concept and what is incestuous (and illegal) in one society may be a close-kin marriage (and legal) in another. Most commonly proscribed as incestuous are sexual relations between first-degree relatives, namely, between parent and child, or between siblings.

Who are the Ammonites of today? ›

The Moabites and the Ammonites are two ancient peoples who are still around today. The Moabites live in Jordan, and the Ammonites live in modern-day Jordan and Iraq. Both groups share a common ancestry, and they continue to interact with each other culturally.


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arielle Torp

Last Updated:

Views: 5547

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arielle Torp

Birthday: 1997-09-20

Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

Phone: +97216742823598

Job: Central Technology Officer

Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.